On direct awards, frameworks, and who gets a fair fight for public consultancy

Join the discussion on LinkedIn at https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7530295235143184385/.

RedQuadrant is on over 400 procurement portals and and more than ten frameworks. I’d say we now see 5-10% as many openly advertised consultancy tenders as we did when we set up in 2009. We’re in the top ten for Crown Commercial tender notifications, so I doubt we’re missing the emails.

Michelle Bee asks how much public sector procurement now runs through frameworks. Well, in our bit of consultancy, even there, 75-85% of framework call-offs go through without further competition. As Michelle says, you can win a place and never see a hint of a competitive opportunity.

Partly, ’twas ever thus. If the buyer’s already decided, I’d sooner have an honest direct award, where the rules allow it, than spend days bidding and get ‘feedback’ strained into the shape of the result. I sympathise with procurement people. And honestly I don’t complain when *we* get the direct award. I would quite like a fair fight when somebody else is the favourite, though 🙂

Why so few open tenders? Permausterity, especially in local government. Some buyers can do more in-house. Others are experimenting with AI, hesitating over AI, waiting for the government agenda to sett/emoney to flow, or waiting for the bits of the public sector currently up in the air to settle (or crash). Meanwhile, every professional body or grant-dependent organisation is ‘trading’ to make ends meet.

Michelle’s fix – find out where the money actually goes before you bid – is tactical. The trouble is that the firm the client trusts gets the work, gets to know them better, and has an even better reference for next time. The buyer has fresh evidence about one firm and the same old ignorance about everybody else. Niching and lockin now govern public sector consulting.

I’d try six more radical changes.

  • Let the buyer hire the person they trust to help work out what’s needed. The price is that their firm sits out the resulting tender. See how much ‘free advice’ is still on offer.
  • For some small, fixed-price jobs, draw lots among firms that meet the criteria.
  • Let buyers name their favourite and say what could change their mind. An outsider who can meet that test can trigger a competition. A buyer who says ‘nothing’ can explain that to the public.
  • Give frontline staff and people who use the service a majority on the selection panel and let them set the criteria.
  • Buyers could revisit repeat awards with the staff who used the advice and see which firms earned the next one.

If you buy consultancy, when did a supplier you’d never worked with last beat the firm you had in mind? What gave them the chance?

Leave a Reply