On the rewards of not succeeding

Join the full conversation on LinkedIn: On the rewards of not succeeding | LinkedIn

To all the radicals I’ve offended before… a piece to my fellow troublemakers. We can sincerely want change and become attached to the rewards of not achieving it.

A pattern

Pauline Lunn asked a question about public service reform – why do we keep describing much the same destination without making it ordinary? https://www.in-controlscotland.org/post/public-service-reform-has-already-been-written. That brought me back to something I keep raising, but I suspect not well. It’s an entirely separate point from all the main barriers to success of radical change (entrenched interests, motivations, structures, anxiety, and so on).

  • A struggle can give us belonging, recognition, and a clear account of who is right. Being the person who keeps telling the truth can become part of who we are.
  • Success might mean sharing authority with people we distrust, discovering that our proposal is incomplete, or giving up a role in which we matter.
  • We can genuinely want the outcome while repeatedly avoiding those changes; being ignored can also spare our preferred solution from ever having to meet realit

These (meagre, psychological) rewards can shape what gets repeated. A group (a support group) might applaud the familiar shibboleths of denunciation and make someone testing a different approach feel disloyal.

Why does it keep turning out this way?

Failure keeps confirming the group’s explanation and identity; a struggle can offer belonging, recognition, and the reassurance of being right. Being ignored can protect a cherished solution from testing. Success may require us to surrender authority, revise our explanation, or give up a role in which we matter.

  • Barry Oshry’s space dynamics helps explain how positions shape responses. Responsibility for the whole can become a burden defended through control. Exposure to other people’s decisions can produce solidarity and opposition. One person can occupy both positions in different relationships. Those responses can intensify one another. A challenge to someone’s authority or moral standing may provoke anxiety. They defend themselves; we interpret that defence as confirmation, and press harder. They find further reason to distrust us.
  • Gregory Bateson called escalating mutual differentiation ‘schismogenesis’. We can become increasingly certain about each other while making change harder. The person explaining the pattern is participating in it, too.

Sandra Beeton asked me some very pertinent questions, which took me down a familiar path – I’m doing it too!

Victim blaming

There’s a real danger of victim blaming here. An earlier exchange about carers with Bridget Gildea exposed a mistake in my argument: doing heroic work doesn’t establish that someone is positioning themselves as a hero. A carer forcing paid professionals to do their jobs may be exercising considerable agency. Their unpaid work gives us no basis for diagnosing a need to be indispensable.

Don’t get me wrong; belonging also sustains people through years of necessary opposition. Having something to gain from a struggle doesn’t establish that you’re prolonging it.

And public bodies retain their obligations. A campaigner’s mixed motives don’t make an unmet need disappear. People shouldn’t have to demonstrate psychological purity to get support or challenge a decision and their rights can’t depend on soothing officials’ anxiety.

Understanding a reciprocal pattern doesn’t distribute power or responsibility equally. But recognising injustice doesn’t settle whether a campaign’s methods are effective. We need to examine what our actions make more likely, including whether a different approach could achieve more. That scrutiny includes consultants whose work helps people cope with arrangements which stay unchanged.

I can provoke the very defensiveness I then claim to explain. An objection to my argument may mean I’ve got it wrong.

‘How are you implicated in the problem you’re addressing?’ – Peter Block

But the question ‘who benefits?’ has to include us. A council can depend on unpaid care, a campaign organisation can depend on continuing grievance, and a consultant can benefit from being the person who explains the failure. Those dependencies can reinforce one another without anyone choosing the overall result.

That includes those of us promoting relational public services. If our ingenious workaround helps one family while leaving the next family needing the same rescue, we need to examine what our work is helping to maintain.

I’d like us to reward people for finding that a favourite argument is wrong, or a familiar tactic is making things worse. Give them somewhere to take that discovery without losing their standing. Keep the rights we’re fighting for explicit, and examine whether our methods are moving power and resources towards the people concerned.

What would success require us to give up – and how would we help one another do it?

Leave a Reply